The Twilight of Advertising

Share
The Twilight of Advertising

The Twilight of Advertising = The Dawn of Intelligent Trust 

From Silicon Valley’s wildest dreams to everyday street conversations, OpenAI’s move into advertising has sparked a subtle yet profound debate: Should AI giants rely on advertising as their revenue stream, or is this approach fundamentally flawed?

Advertising, once the backbone of the internet economy, has undergone dramatic transformations, from the traffic-driven Web1 era of Yahoo and Google, and Facebook, to the attention-hungry Web2 world dominated by TikTok, YouTube, X and Instagram. Yet today, we stand at the precipice of a seismic shift: transitioning from an economy built on capturing attention to one centered on aiding decisions, ushered in by the rise of AI agents.

But let’s return briefly to our opening question: Can OpenAI genuinely thrive on advertising?

In the age of Web1, the game was simple, as web traffic equaled revenue. Platforms boasting the most eyeballs commanded the greatest profits. Moving into the Web2 landscape, advertising refined itself, burrowing deeper into user behaviors, emotions, and subconscious impulses. Every like, every scroll, every lingering glance became data points fueling precision-targeted ads. Yet this model quickly approached a natural limit: human attention, finite and easily fatigued.

Today, people willingly pay for YouTube Premium just to escape “precisely annoying” advertisements. This signals that the attention economy, once so lucrative, has plateaued. Attention alone can no longer sustain the enormous valuations and dreams held by the tech titans of our time.

Amidst this change, trust is undergoing a fascinating evolution. The conventional advertising model built a bridge of attention between consumers and brands. However, as AI integrates deeper into daily life, this bridge trembles under the weight of a new reality: trust shifting from platforms to personalized AI agents.

People are no longer asking AI “What can I buy?” Instead, they are asking, “What is the best choice for me?” This seemingly minor shift fundamentally alters how decisions are made, both personally and professionally.

On the consumer side, rather than scrolling endlessly or comparing deals, future consumers simply instruct their AI: “Book the best-value flight,” “Find the ideal international school for my child,” or “What supplements suit my health profile?”

The investment sector experiences even deeper disruptions. Investors previously depended heavily on market reports, expert analyses, and gut instinct. Now, AI provides immediate, comprehensive, and nuanced insights, integrating massive data flows, pinpointing subtle market shifts, and accurately evaluating risks and opportunities. Trust in AI is surpassing traditional analytics, reshaping financial strategies and practices fundamentally.

This transformative shift means advertising itself must evolve dramatically. No longer just a showcase aimed at capturing attention, future advertising will become seamlessly embedded within AI-driven decision-making processes. Users will no longer view ads directly; instead, their AI agents will analyze, compare, simulate, and execute decisions transparently and effortlessly.

In the Web4 era, advertising targets not users directly, but the algorithms guiding their choices. Businesses no longer compete merely for exposure but for AI recognition as the best, most trustworthy option. Demonstrating value and trustworthiness will grant brands privileged positions within AI recommendation engines, thus reshaping the competitive landscape.

Yet, OpenAI’s foray into traditional advertising may only be a sideline narrative. The true driver behind astronomical valuations aka the “dream-to-market” ratio is the immense creativity and productivity unleashed when individuals merge with AI agents (OpenAI Codex, Claude Code, OpenClaw, to name a few). This “intelligent emergence” means anyone can become a self-contained, hyper-efficient “One-Person Company,” seamlessly moving from inspiration to execution. This represents the true, thrilling promise of our AI-driven future.

Consider real-world scenarios:

Imagine an entrepreneur from mainland China, navigating the complexities of setting up a company in Hong Kong, acquiring residency, educating their children abroad, and managing overseas assets. Rather than diving into endless searches or consuming countless ads, they entrust an AI agent to chart the optimal course, assess risks, and recommend top service providers.

Picture a homemaker seeking the perfect nutritional supplements. No longer influenced by advertisements or social media endorsements, she consults her AI health assistant, which uses detailed personal medical data to recommend and procure precisely what she needs.

Visualize a global executive frequently organizing complex business travels. He no longer compares prices on travel sites but simply instructs his AI assistant to optimize every aspect of his upcoming global itinerary seamlessly.

Imagine an investor requiring sophisticated portfolio management and asset allocation strategies tailored to specific risk profiles and financial goals. Instead of traditional advisory firms, they rely on AI-driven analyses that dynamically monitor and adjust investments in real-time.

As advertising’s twilight deepens, what new dawn emerges?

It is the dawn of an unprecedented “Intelligent Trust Economy.” In this new paradigm, advertising no longer comes in the form of embedded content or influencer endorsements. Instead, it is built upon rigorous transparency, fairness, and efficiency enabled by AI agents. Trust between users and their AI agents forms a virtuous cycle 🔄, successful decisions boost trust, encouraging further reliance on the agent, thus refining future outcomes and intensifying this positive feedback loop.

This represents the true miracle of intelligent emergence, as every individual empowered by AI becomes the master of their own consumer choices, investment decisions, and life strategies, unlocking unlimited potential and creating boundless value.

In this new epoch, the “dream-to-market” ratio is no longer merely the fantasy of tech giants but becomes tangible reality driven by the genuine creativity and productivity of AI-enhanced individuals.

Advertising won’t vanish entirely. It will quietly recede into the background, silently embedded in the fabric of intelligent decision-making systems, serving users so seamlessly that it becomes invisible.

Thus marks the true twilight of advertising and the magnificent dawn of an Intelligent Trust Economy. ❤️‍🔥

Read more

毕业生初职指南

毕业生初职指南

初职之阶渐隐,当培筑世之能工巧匠 引言 我曾雇佣人才,也曾不得不裁撤他们。 这寥寥数语之沉重,胜过千百职业指南。因我非袖手旁观之人,而是亲历事态冷暖之士。 这十载光阴里,作为管理合伙人,我所延揽核心职位不超过三十人,而因新冠疫情、经济衰退及人工智能崛起之势,裁员逾三百人。这并非空言,而是沉甸甸的亲身经历:充满人情世故,代价高昂,教训深刻。 今日,有一言或令人不适,却甚为紧要:至少在未来五至十年,或永久,我已不再考虑雇佣传统的初级职位。 苛刻乎?未必。 实则,此乃为毕业生提早饮下清醒之红丸,以便尽早看清世事,转而适应,并重新掌握人生主动权。 传统初职之凋零 过去,初职之设乃基于一种简单的社会默契:新毕业生经验尚浅,仅凭学历稍示潜力;公司则录用新人,投入资源栽培成长,以期日后得用。此模式过去行之有效,企业大量需要初级分析师、程序员、研究员等角色。 然而,人工智能正迅速取代这一基础层次。 此种取代并非剧烈,而是持续而无情的。今日,

By Robin Xie
广告的黄昏

广告的黄昏

广告的黄昏🌆,信任的黎明🌅  从”流量经济”到“注意力经济”到“决策经济” 从硅谷最狂野的梦想到街头巷尾的现实需求,OpenAI开始投放广告了。这一举动,在科技圈不算新闻,却点亮了一个耐人寻味的信号灯:AI巨头靠广告赚钱,是理所当然,还是背道而驰? 广告,作为过去几十年支撑互联网经济的基石,历经门户网站的流量时代,到社交平台和短视频平台的注意力时代,如今正在走向一个前所未有的范式转折点。我们正在从注意力经济向决策经济跨越,而这一跨越的桥梁,就是AI代理入口。 让我们先回到最初的问题:OpenAI靠广告赚钱了吗?简单的回答是:赚到了,但这更主要是为了让“免费用户”看上去不再像负债的行为,而且广告正在沦为所有AI入口公司的“支线剧情”,而非“主线任务”。 广告是商业世界最古老的游戏之一。雅虎、谷歌、百度、脸书这样的Web1平台时代,靠的是流量变现。谁的网站访问量大,谁就有最大的广告位,谁就赚得最多。 Web2时代,YouTube、Instagram、TikTok、 X 等注意力平台兴起。

By Robin Xie
现代之神灯精灵

现代之神灯精灵

那是一个寻常的周五夜晚,天凉如水,我与Bran相依而坐,共赏迪士尼经典之作《阿拉丁》。表面看来,母子观影,其乐融融;而我内心,却暗藏着一段巧妙安排。 此前我曾向Bran展示过强大的智能代理Codex,已经生成了很多小游戏。 他总能在这些世界里挑剔出瑕疵,封我为“专职除虫师”。今夜,我欲借影片,婉转告诉他:“神灯精灵”与我们当今使用的人工智能之间,有着异曲同工之妙。 影片伊始,我低声相告:“Bran,你且看,这神灯精灵就如同Codex一般,只要轻拭神灯,说出适宜的言语,便可呼风唤雨、点石成金。”他目光半疑半信,似对我这哲思比喻未完全心服,但仍依偎我肩头,静静观看。 而当影幕渐次展开,我心中却别有洞天。那原本熟稔于心的旧日故事,竟忽而透露出全新哲理:阿拉丁、茉莉公主、贾方,尤其是神灯精灵,他们真正渴求者,非权势财富,而是身份之自由。 阿拉丁渴盼摆脱贫穷谎言之枷锁;茉莉公主则欲挣脱宫廷繁华中规矩礼法之囚笼;神灯精灵虽神通广大,却只愿解脱千年束缚;即便权欲熏心如贾方者,

By Robin Xie